Avoiding the Overloaded Sandwich: Balancing Cognitive Load

I love sandwiches - but I do not like a super messy one that takes away the feeling of eating it! Imagine a super loaded sandwich that becomes a towering, confusing mess, and every bite overwhelms your taste buds. This scenario is a lot like cognitive overload in Instructional Design.

Let's unwrap the layers of Intrinsic, Extrinsic, and Germane Load and see how they're the key ingredients to creating a satisfying and effective learning experience.

Intrinsic Load: The Essential Fillings

Think of learning like building a sandwich. The core elements—the meat, cheese, and veggies—are the intrinsic load. It's the essential information learners need to understand. Just as too much filling can spill out, an excessive intrinsic load can overwhelm learners' brains.

Extrinsic Load: The Presentation and Packaging

Imagine trying to eat a sandwich with layers falling all over the place. This struggle is like the extrinsic load. It's the extra "stuff" around the core content—like complex visuals, long paragraphs, or unclear instructions. Too much extrinsic load, like too many toppings, makes it hard to focus on the main ingredients.

Germane Load: The Perfect Seasoning

This is the right blend of flavour in a sandwich that brings forward its unique flavor profile. It is the connection of the new information with existing knowledge to form a schema. For instance, when learning new software, relating the new commands to previously learned software — it makes the learning process much more enjoyable and efficient.

Creating a Perfect Sandwich: Practical Tips

  • Chunking: Just as you'd layer your sandwich, break content into smaller, manageable pieces.
  • Visual Appeal: Add relevant images to clarify concepts, but don't go overboard—like not drowning your sandwich in sauce.
  • Interactive Bites: Include activities that let learners interact with the content, just as you'd savor each bite of your sandwich.
  • Real-world Scenarios: Integrate relatable examples, like adding a favorite ingredient, to help learners connect new knowledge to their existing experiences.

Why Balance Matters: The Recipe for Effective Learning

  • Efficiency: By managing intrinsic load, you ensure learners focus on core concepts without feeling swamped.
  • Clarity: Taming extrinsic load means presenting content in a way that's clear, concise, and visually appealing.
  • Engagement: Striking the right balance of germane load encourages active processing, aiding in better understanding and retention.
The Art of Instructional Design
Much like crafting a sandwich, Instructional Design hinges on finding the right balance. Avoiding cognitive overload is like ensuring your sandwich isn't too overwhelming to enjoy. When we understand and manage intrinsic, extrinsic, and germane load, we create learning experiences that leave learners satisfied, engaged, and ready for more. As we layer our instructional design (in the perfectly crafted sandwich) —we create a delicious mix that harmonizes to create a memorable and fulfilling learning journey. That made me hungry for effective learning!

Read more like this